Score: 10

"Lovely"

submission: [[=In A Trance=]]

date: September 8, 2007

The right sounds, the right build-up, there is really nothing more to say!

Lovely.

Peace

Score: 10

"Sublime"

submission: {dj-N} The Euphoria

date: September 4, 2007

Very well written and put together. There isn't much more to say...

Score: 9

"Good, original but not great"

submission: [Kriz] - Fluctuations

date: September 3, 2007

This song contains a lot of musical effort and you can hear that. The melody was good, the rythm was good, but it was as if it lacked a certain build-up. I thought that when going to the end, you'd make a climax with the chords and a new instrument, but you didn't and now I feel like the number just lingers for a bit and fades out, though that's cool too :-)

5/5
9/10

Peace

Score: 8

"Nice, but low quality"

submission: Daze

date: September 2, 2007

The song is actually very nice, but I've got the feeling there's a mini mini gap between every loop you made. Maybe that's because you put the bitrate too low? Or did you intend it that way? Anyways, it feels like there's a gap that shouldn't be there...

5/5
8/10

Peace

Score: 4

"Not coherent..."

submission: First but not least

date: September 2, 2007

It sounded like you wanted to put too much different things in the song. They don't sound too wel together. Try letting your different pieces of music blend in eachother.

Though the designated driver thingy was cool :-P

4/10
2/5

Peace

Score: 3

"Not that catchy"

submission: _-*_-*(Sky Drop)*-_*-_

date: August 31, 2007

I had the feeling you had quite the nice instruments, but didn't use them well. I didn't notice the strings only on the end where they were the only thing playing. It's rather boring to have the same piano loop playing over and over, though the piano-loop-thing wasn't too bad, I'd suggest try making two or three loops that fit with each other and try to have them blend in to eachother to make the song more interesting.

1/5
3/10

Peace

Score: 9

"Good quality"

submission: Down to the Roots

date: August 17, 2007

Sound quality is good and this raises the question: which program did you use to make this?
If you did this on your own guitar, I take my hat off (might I have been wearing a hat), you put some good techniques in there and still were able to play fluently.

You were quite right for keeping the song a bit short, nobody wants to listen to a 10 minute-long solo (not on NG anyways :p) and it starts to bore quite easily, but this is about the good lenght for a song like this.

5/5
9/10
Rock on =)

Score: 8

"Good"

submission: FFX - To Zanarkand (PianoRmx)

date: August 15, 2007

Not a very rich song, but I guess the original isn't either.
Nice work on the piano!

4/5
8/10

Peace

Score: 9

"Good slow Drum 'N Bass"

submission: SpK*) - Fury Tragic

date: August 15, 2007

First part is the best sounding, but not the most interesting part if you'd ask me.
It sounds pretty sweet en swelling, but I've got the feeling you could have done more with the piano-like instrument you used.

After the faster part (0:00 - 1:14) comes one of the best parts of slower Drum 'N Bass I've ever heard. You've proved that Drum 'N Base doesn't need to be fast and flashing like there's no tomorrow.

Nice works on those percussions too!

4/5
9/10

Peace

Score: 9

"Nice!"

submission: Enya - Evening Falls (cover)

date: August 15, 2007

Sounds pretty sweet. Calming and inspirational. Can't help but thinking this song should go with a film (a rather emotional one), but oh well, that's just suggestive thinking.
I wish I could play the poiano like that, so fluently, I wouldn't hesitate a second to put some of it in my tunes, but alas :(

Nice version,
peace